Ok.. I'm surprised at how solid this actually is. Nose...not much happening. Sweet. Some caramel, apple. Palate however is pleasant. Caramel apple, vanilla. Quite lovely. Much better than the original. Now, I drank whistle pig 10 after, and yea...it blew this shit away, but this was solid. The finish is where it just has nothing really. Ok, the nose and finish are next to nothing haha. Still though, much better than I had expected.