dhsilv2
Joseph Magnus Cigar Blend Bourbon
Bourbon — Indiana, USA
Reviewed
May 5, 2022 (edited April 25, 2023)
Always a treat when I get the honor of trying one of these. This sadly is just a sample i received, but I'll do my best here as always. This one is the seven swans a swimming batch 66 at 64.85. This likely is the barton/MGP blend with most likely the 21% rye MGP and I suspect we'll be in that 12-20 year age range. Those are at least my assumptions going in.
Nose - Right off the bat this is a distinctly candied and very sweet example of cigar blend. Rye notes do come out, giving hints of smoke, leather, tobacco, and well just regular old rye. Lightly caramel covered apples are here, likely the barton notes. Here I get almost waxy fall leaves, not the generally just fall leaves but there's a bit of a wax over coat. Heavily spiced and some good citrus notes. I'm more in the apples going into lemon zone, but you could argue the spices might remind you of some type of orange influenced spiced product.
Taste - Cinnamon and spice...chocolate cake or perhaps some dried pastry, vanilla, oak, leather, apple cider, mint leaves, and yes some grape notes. Very spicy, very tobacco/leather heavy for sure. The overall whisky is very sweet upfront and on the nose. And then really nicely spiced and oaky on the finish. Thinking the "kentucky" bourbon is 14+ year stuff which is really where that distillery hits a sweet spot.
Going 3.75 stars. Maybe should be 4? Really exceptional bourbon. But you know me, I'm a hard grader.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Really great to hear you still have some 36% rye mgp, I thought those were gone!
@WhiskeyBlender Well, you've set such expectations, it's hard to live up to them! That said on a sample I always get a bit conservative. 3.5 + I consider pretty exceptional in general. This one left me a bit unsure on 3.75 vs 4.00. I try to save the 4.0 for really really special stuff. It was right there. For me there is nothing pretty low about that score or this one. I know others throw around 4+ scores more than me.
Hey there @dhsilv2. Yikes, a 3.75 is pretty low! Sorry to hear that it didn't hold up to what you were expecting. At any rate, just wanted to say that it is a blend of the 36% and 21% MGP Bourbon with the Bartons. The age ranges are about 14.8 to 20 years old.