If you like the 16 you should like this one as well, whilst not quite as refined or rounded as it’s 16 year old sibling it still presents a bold and Smokey flavor. Keeping in mind it has had half the aging of its sibling I personally think it stands up very well as a young Islay. I purchased this on offer and i am still debating it if would be worth it’s usual asking price. 3.75/5