Tried this in a tasting of several Arran whiskys and this was my 2nd favourite after the sauterne finish. Def broke the general rule I had that older is better when it comes to whisky as I didn't rate it's 18 brother as highly. Prob more of a 3.5 for me. Update a couple of years and many a great whisky later. 3.25 at best. Little flavour.