Soba45
Noah's Mill Bourbon
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
July 20, 2018 (edited September 14, 2018)
I read an article about appreciation of blending and the obsession with single barrel and it struck a cord. Single barrel is put on a pedestal but really like wine making the human element shouldn't stop at harvest time. Blending is an art form and here it's done well. Ainiseed, burnt caramel and much much more going on here. One part of me is how can this retain its 5 star if I didn't give Pappy 15 and George Stag 2017 a similar rating? Still its $70 USD. Yes that's right folks less than a 15th of the price of the Pappy on the secondary market. Its got beautiful earthy depth, one you can taste the history on. Faded burnt caramel, rich but mellow oak, hint of dryness, cherry in the background. In todays world VFM is stratospheric. How much should VFM contribute to a score? The original score was 4.5 and I'm hesitant to lower. It more than held it's own against the winkle family. Update 29/9. The story of my life.. love a sample and a while later buy a bottle.. in the mean time quality plummets...it's a Glenfiddich and bourbon blender speciality these days. This sadly has gone down hill. It was a 4.75 dram in its heyday..now a 3.75 to 4.
70.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@Scott_E @PBMichiganWolverine Cheers. Yeah its a great dram alright. I preferred the pappy 15 but the difference isnt great in terms of preference and yet the prices.....I think maybe I should have rounded down as the 2nd time round it didn't blow me away as much but then I was getting bourbon fatigue at bit by that point. Either way still a great dram worth trying.
Just went searching for it. Alas! I must have finished it.
@Scott_E still $60 now. Seems like this one hasn’t fortunately skyrocketed. Sounds like a must-try
I found my old review. I paid $60 for this two years ago.
Nice review. This is a really good bourbon. I have an open bottle somewhere in may cabinets and my have to dig it out. I can’t seem to easily locate my review since the update to the app, from ages ago. I recall paying about $40 for this and was curious to try against its brethren Rowan’s Creek.