LeeEvolved
Compass Box Flaming Heart (Sixth Edition)
Blended Malt — Scotland
Reviewed
January 19, 2019 (edited July 17, 2019)
It’s that special time again. Time for John Glaser and the guys at Compass Box Whisky to release another edition of Flaming Heart. This is their semi-annual, heavily peated blend meant to appease the “peat-heads” of the scotch world. It’s been 3 years since the last release, though- maybe John and the gang has been getting stretched too thin with all the bespoke bottlings. Cut that out, lol.
Anyway, this is the 6th Edition and they decided to add another layer to this blend by supplementing the blend with some sherried whisky. Why? I don’t have a clue- I just know the price has risen on this one by $20-25 and I don’t really like that. But, we’ll leave that gripe until the end.
This one is pale yellow in the Glencairn and makes some watery legs and tiny drops on the rim. It’s bottled at 48.9% and, like all CBW blends, has no added color and isn’t chill filtered.
The nose is ashtray smoke and fresh ground peppercorn up front- so strong I actually recoiled a bit when I first went in. There’s tar and alcohol steadily present and I got a bit of sweet vanilla over time- a lot of time, actually: 40 minutes or so. It took a long time for the fire to burn itself down. I’m not complaining, however, just documenting it.
The palate brings more abrasive smoke and BBQ’d rubber (if that makes sense). The mouthcoat is still buttery with the faintest of sweetness finally bleeding through all the smoke and peat. Dried raisins is about all of the sherry influence I get despite there being almost 30% of the blend being sourced from sherry casked Deanston. The 40% from Caol Ila and 8% from the blended, French Oak casks are carrying the load here. As they should- this is meant to be a fireball of smoke and heat. It still predominately is, thankfully.
The finish is long and smoky with more ashtray and burnt leather. It’s hot and dry and everything you love about true peat monsters (pun intended).
Overall, these are still in my wheelhouse. The sherry influence escaped me here but I’m actually happy about that- well, except for the increase in price. I had to pay $130 for this bottle and I feel like that’s $30 too much. I miss my old $100 Flaming Hearts, I really do. I’ll also gladly forego the added sherry next time, thank you. But realistically, this is still a fantastic dram if you like your peat. 4.25 stars. Cheers.
130.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@AvcHK - thanks for the kind words. I’m glad I can hopefully add a bit of help when people are searching for something new to try.
Great review @LeeEvolved. I don't know how much time I have spent reading your thoughts while standing in front of a whisky shelf but, it is always helpful!
I also just paid $130 for this bottle. After No Name I’m going to trust them until they give me a reason not to. I haven’t been up and down their range but it is amazing and both Hedonism and Peat Monster are pretty tasty as well
@LeeEvolved - great review!
@LeeEvolved probably declining stocks, considering they already discontinued the Asyla
@PBMichiganWolverine - I think it’s because of the added sherry whisky. I wonder if it’s because they weren’t happy with the sole, peaty blend or they really were experimenting. You’d think that since it’s Flaming Heart they look for a similar profile every time but they weren’t able to duplicate it with the stock they had on hand, so they added the extra dimension to make it more palatable and that added cost that had to be passed on to the consumer.
Doesn’t surprise me that they’ve increased prices, but a 30% hike is a bit much. I wonder if their entire core range has gone up or just this because of the sherry influence?
@SolanaRoots - actually, it would be easier to list the ones I was disappointed in. Their stuff is usually solid to great each time. Sometimes their $300 limited releases miss the mark, in my opinion, and when that happens it’s usually the price that makes me the most upset. The whisky is still good, just overpriced. My favorites to this point, though, would have to be: 1) This Is Not A Luxury 2) No Name 3) Lost Blend 4) King St NY Blend 5) The Circus 6) Hedonism I was disappointed with 3 Year Deluxe, Phenomonology, Double Single and some of the King St Marrying Cask bottles.
Great review as usual @LeeEvolved
Man, great review @LeeEvolved - this one sounds outstanding. And sorry to ask, but can you give us your fave 5 (or 6-7) bottles from Compass Box? Cheers