ContemplativeFox
Southern Comfort Original
Herbal/Spice Liqueurs — USA
Reviewed
August 28, 2020 (edited October 24, 2020)
Rating: 0/23
Yes, if you read that rating line up above, you can predict the general direction that this is going to go. TLDR: Do not drink.
N: There is something alarmingly artificial on the nose here. All of my instincts are shrieking "Chemicals! Do not drink!" It has a light smell to it - no hint of age. There is nothing here that resembles whiskey. I've never smelled anything quite like it. Except maybe a particularly foul energy drink.I get some rubber and alcohol hidden behind the nauseating fruity sweet smell. Nothing about that sentence or the experience that inspired it makes me want to come within a mile of this ever again. But I suppose I will have to taste it...
P: It tastes just like it smells, but so so much worse! I'd heard the rumors about how awful this was, but I didn't believe that they were entirely true. What a mistake! This is quite possibly the foulest spirit I have ever tasted! It tastes tremendously artificial with a loathsome bitterness. It's surprisingly thin as well. There is nothing resembling aging here. It's like Seagram's 7 cranked down to -1. It isn't just that there's a bit of rubber flavor. There's something vaguely fruity and also a faint herbal hint. There's something vaguely resembling caramel somewhere, but it's all just awful. Imagine the grossest gummy or jelly candy you can and then replace the sugar with five times as much of the worst artificial sweetener you can imagine. It's like the worst energy drink ever conceived. There isn't a single redeeming thing about this palate or experience. It is actually physically making my stomach convulse. I wouldn't say that it's quite nauseating, but it's pretty freaking close. Oh, no, do I actually need to drink some of this ?! Even sipping and spitting is miserable enough. What monster invented this?!?!
F: I'm struggling to describe this. Not for the reason I did with the palate that it tastes like some sort of sci-fi chemical waste plant mutant drink, but because I'm struggling to swallow it and then not immediately rinse my mouth out. I'm down to my last 15ml or so (thankfully), but I still haven't actually been able to taste the finish. OK, I've finally gotten it a little bit. It's quite bitter. The rubber comes through more and the worst aspect of the fruit lingers, but it's the alcohol that really stands out. The only improvement here is that the worst of the artificial sugar bite is gone. It's just amazing how little character there is here that the alcohol can stand out, yet the flavor is so actively bad. It makes me want to cry.
I have tasted over 1,000 spirits, beers, and wines, and I've even given at least one perfect score. This is the first time I've ever given a zero. There is nothing to redeem this abomination. It is just amazing that no matter how I look at it, no matter what use case I imagine, I just can't find anything that isn't bad about this bottle of garbage. If anything, this tells me that I've been too lenient with my higher ratings up until now because I've always found faults, even when giving a perfect score. There is simply nothing to redeem Southern Comfort.
Side-by-side with Clan MacGregor (yes, a totally unreasonable comparison aside from them both being awful), I would take the Clan MacGregor by a fair margin. This is even harsh like Clan MacGregor. It's a 1 to 2. So, if this is lower than that...
If you forced me to drink this, you would quite literally be violating the Geneva Conventions on torture. It is just that bad. Zero. Zero. Zero!
13.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Southern Comfort was the original Fireball that was overly sweetened(way overly) and spiced but not with the cinnamon heat. I laugh at people who drink this, the same way I laugh at "fireballers", "so sad to be you". If you are drinking this, Fireball or Jaegarmeister, you should really start thinking about reconsidering life choices.
@cascode Sounds like your good tastes go way back! Also sounds like this thread is now the unofficial Southern Comfort support group. Anyone else who's suffered from this vile drink, please do chime in :)
@ContemplativeFox I drank this once, at an end-of-year party when I was in my final year of high school in 1975. Three girls brought a bottle because it was apparently their favourite thing at the time. I had one swig and have never touched it since. One of the worst things I've ever tasted.
@claptonfan756 I can never be friends with those people, but I can appreciate that they are just as happy as I am while spending far less for a drink.
It’s strange but people who have developed a palate for whisky can’t stand Southern Comfort, and people who like Southern Comfort can’t stand real whisky. Simple as that.
@Bourbon_Obsessed_Lexington Can't say I endorse that use case, but props for finding one! Would definitely try it if I had any of this left (before pouring the rest of the bottle down the drain and hoping that doing so didn't create any mutant sewer gators).
@Ctrexman Good golly! And I thought my experience was bad! I'm really sorry to hear that.
@WhiskeyLonghorn Happy to do it. There's something satisfying in at least confirming that the stuff you're pretty sure is bad actually as bad.
Got violently ill from this ages ago......just the thought of this repulsive monstrosity makes me nauseous
We’ve all taken one for the team now and again. Thanks for stepping up on this one.
Bury it in coke, pelt it with ice and make the brain cells go away. At least I think that’s what I used it for some 15y ago, but oddly can’t remember. Probably the chemicals.
@TheWhiskeyJug Glad to save you the misery of wondering and trying it again :)
@CKarmios Haha, thanks! My dad has spent years railing on this off and on. I'm glad to have finally tried it, but I didn't think it would be as bad as it actually was!
Haven't had this in about 20 years, sounds like I'm not missing anything!
I just hope you don’t end up developing some kind of PTSD after this ordeal