-
ContemplativeFox
Reviewed January 8, 2022 (edited August 26, 2022)Rating: 18/23 N: After several minutes of aeration, I get vanilla, caramel, banana (maybe a hint of orange and pineapple too), musty/dusty wood, spices. It's very nice and much more mature than when I initially poured it. I wouldn't call it a super complex nose, but it's very rich and enticing, though perhaps a little on the sweet side. P: It burns, but it's sweet with a big fullness and richness. Some char that doesn't quite make it into the fireworks range. The wood is there and it has some a nice gesture in the musty/dusty direction that integrates well with the char and leads nicely into the vanilla. The caramel fills out the sweetness, but it ends up perhaps a bit too sweet. I get less banana than I'd feared, with more orange peel and a little pineapple instead. Something kind of dry and tannic, approaching leather a little at points. I'm having trouble identifying the particular spices, but there must be at least a little clove. Not the most complex palate, but there's a decent amount going on and it's absolutely packed with flavor. I wish it burned less though. Water really helps to tame that burn, while also bringing out more toasty flavors that border on nutty and highlighting the time in the barrel. I also get some actual fireworks and hogo. This is actually a fair bit better with a splash of water, so I'm a bit surprised by the chosen proof. That said, a bit too high is far far better than a bit too low when it comes to proof. F: Kind of numb from the burn. There's some bitterness here too. Faint sweetness lingers still, but it dryness with some astringency and the bitterness overpower it. - Conclusion - This is a great rum. It isn't blowing my mind, but it's a very enjoyable sipper that isn't super expensive. I did prefer the Foursquare Premise though and it was a fair bit cheaper when I got my hands on it. If this were a bourbon, I'd guess that it was a mix of ones in the 4 to 10 year range poured from the neck. With some air, the youthfulness falls back substantially. OK, after much consideration and comparison, I've found this to be a lovely rum. I'm thinking it's in the 18 to 19 range. I did consider a 17 for a bit, but I think this is better than that. I'm going with 18.65.0 USD per Bottle -
modlyzko
Reviewed December 19, 2021 (edited June 20, 2022)Really complete toasty, brown sugary rum. Kinda shameful to mix as well as sip, but it's a damn sturdy mixer, so sue me 😳62.0 USD per Bottle -
modlyzko
Reviewed November 14, 2021 (edited July 13, 2024)Really solid aged rum... spicy, sweet, spiced, leathery. Perfect to sip but actually mixable too.63.0 USD per Bottle -
ctbeck11
Reviewed October 17, 2021 (edited October 19, 2021)Nose - citrusy molasses, strawberry, grass, salted caramel, pineapple, grape, cherry, floral notes, raspberry, pink lemonade, allspice, moderate ethanol burn. Taste - grassy molasses, strawberry, raspberry, pineapple, white pepper, lemon pith, orange zest, clove, allspice, mint, caramel, cola, moderate alcohol bite, finishing medium length with sweet molasses, jammy red fruit, and citrus flavors. Here we have the port-finished counterpart to the sherried Premise release. Both are 10 Year products, with Detente being bottled at a slightly higher 51% ABV. The port influence is front and center. The standard bittersweet Foursquare molasses note is present, but jammy red fruits dominate the nose and palate on this one. Strawberry, raspberry, cherry, even some pink lemonade are easily identifiable. Overall this is delicious rum, but as with Premise, it’s not my favorite Foursquare profile. It’s sweeter than their more traditional offerings, but certainly not cloying like the additive-laced rums can be. At $75 a bottle, I think this is a solid value. However, I’ll continue to reserve my money for the older, strictly ex-bourbon releases, as they’re generally more my speed. Another big thank you to @ContemplativeFox for the generous sample!
Results 11-20 of 33 Reviews