Swahili1
Milam & Greene Port Finished Rye
Rye — Indiana , USA
Reviewed
January 1, 2021 (edited March 12, 2022)
Nose- the nose is prickly. I get a fair amount of fresh raspberry and musty wood on the first whiff. There is some anise in the background and some white pepper notes. Nice nose, and nothing I would expect from MGP rye (dill, vanilla, all spice).
Taste- upon entry this does not taste like rye at all, but rather a high rye bourbon. In fact I get a dusty sweet corn taste followed by strawberry jam, currants like you might find in a scone, some raisins, and oak. It is a bit drying and has a few hot spots, but all in all a good sip.
Finish- finish is medium to longer with notes of wood, jelly, and white pepper. A pretty good balance.
Overall- This is a nice surprise. It really showcases what a nice port finished rye can be. The finish gives a nice jaminess to it. The port seems to impart an aged mustier taste reminescent of what one might find in say Wild Turkey to what I think might otherwise be a younger rye. Reminds me alot of some of the finished Highwest Rye I have recently had, or a great sub for Midwinter Night's Dram if you can't find it. I enjoyed this one and can't wait to put it in a manhattan cockatil.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
I did that same side by side and I agree. Although I preferred the MWND, the Milam and Greene was certainly a contender. The one difference was the MG enters a bit hot. But it is a quality sip more easily found@Brandon-Cook
I did a side-by-side with MWND to understand if this is a poor man’s, good budget substitute, and I have to say my evaluation was very close with yours. Glad to see someone else saw this through a similar lens. I believe another difference I saw is a bit more of the rye funk in the Milam vs the MWND. I also felt the MWND displayed a bit more anise. It felt like this might been a difference in finishing time, though I’ve yet to put in the time to research how long each is finished.