ctbeck11
Elijah Craig 18 Year Single Barrel Bourbon
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
January 9, 2021 (edited August 20, 2021)
Nose - rich caramel, brown sugar, apple, strong cinnamon, berry, vanilla, marshmallow, powdered sugar, chocolate, spicy oak char, grape, leather, tobacco, cherry, custard, black pepper, moderate ethanol burn.
Taste - salted caramel, cherry, apple, tannic oak, butter, cinnamon, nutmeg, grape, black pepper, brown sugar, ginger, powdered sugar, vanilla, marshmallow, chocolate, leather, berry, spicy tobacco, cola, moderate alcohol bite, finishing medium length with rich salted caramel, moderately tannic oak, cinnamon, and black pepper flavors.
This is a really nice. The nose and palate are both rich and delicate with strong caramel, leather, and tobacco balanced effectively with natural fruitiness and creamy, marshmallowy sweetness. It’s a bit overoaked and bitter, but the lower-than-cask proof keeps it from veering into unpleasantly tannic and dry territory. It’s just really good bourbon, but not at all mind blowing. And I’d still pick my ECBP batches over this one if I was forced to choose.
I wouldn’t call this a good value at $150 MSRP. Hell, I can get ECBP releases for $60 fairly easily near me. However, the last time the VA ABC had this is stock, there were lines around the building. Secondary seems to be in the $200 - $300 range, which is absurd. It’s absolutely not worth over $100, at least in my personal opinion. That said, it’s really solid and I’d be happy to have a glass of this any day.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@Adrian-Popitan Yep, I agree that $150 for an 18 year old bourbon isn’t ridiculous in the current market. My issue with this one in particular is that I didn’t like it as much as their ECBP releases I can find fairly easily for half the price. Couple that with the fact that most people who don’t win a lottery have to pay $250+ for a bottle, and the value proposition seems dubious to me. But hey, that’s my subjective experience of it. Others love this and happily pay the secondary prices for a bottle. I’ll keep buying the ECBP releases and maybe pony up for a pour of this every once in a while when I see it at a restaurant.
I collect scotch. I can tell you a good 18 yr scotch is often always over 100$ & something like a Macallan 18 is 300$. Knowing that bourbon is made in fresh new barrels without coloring added, I would say 150$ is more than a fair price for something of that age & scarcity.
Precision review 👍