dhsilv2
Very Olde St. Nick Ancient Estate 13 Year Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey (Lot 1)
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
February 22, 2021 (edited April 7, 2021)
So quick info, just pass on this. It's a joke beyond words. Just pass, these guys are putting out trash and charging these stupid prices. It's comical. But I was suckered in.
Nose - Honestly, it's a weird nose. Kinda comes off like a young, ethanol forward bourbon.
Taste - first off this feels like water and then kicks on the back like 200 proof, wtf is going on here? OK so it's vanilla and oak. I mean there's not really much more going on. It's almost as if someone flavored vanilla vodka with bourbon and oak.
Just for sanity I poured me some belle meade reserve, all those rye spices and lovely balanced sweet and spicy notes. Lovely. The 400 dollar bourbon? It's sweeter, but it's almost like it tastes like a watered down bourbon as in I just added too much water, but then hits with alcohol.
Water - oddly enough the water seems to be teasing out some things on the nose. Bringing out more bourbon oils and more of a mellow creamy note. The nose at first was crazy closed off. Getting a bit of odd mushroom sauce notes here, but mostly just oak and vanilla.
Water Pallet - it's still pretty thin but it's not more thin than before. I'm getting more spice and tannins. The finish is medium but it's better now than before.
Going back again to the belle meade, it's younger but it's not young. The flavors are rich and full as hell. Great whisky.
The st nick is coming alive slowly for me and it's not a bad bourbon. I can't even guess where this is from. There's a legit note of buffalo trace with way more oak and bite than normal. Overall I'm scoring it a 2.25, but if price factors in at all, it's a 0.
Seriously screw these guys.
399.99
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Thanks for the heads-up @dhsilv2 ! I was eyeing this one for a sec. Hard pass now.
@Bourbon_Obsessed_Lexington I'll have a review up on rare perfection 12 year soon as well. I took a HECK of one for the team.
@dhsilv2 we need a BiB revolt of 2021 - name your distillery and rickhouse, leave it NCF and CS and THEN take my money... sadly this will never happen. Way to take one for the team and may the odds be ever in your favor.
@PBMichiganWolverine 100% man. hell what was cs and why did you add water is another question. instead we are asked to blindly spend our money.
@dhsilv2 great review. Personally I was always hesitant on piling the trigger for these St Nick’s. My belief has always been that if I’m going to be paying over $150, I do want more transparency—-I’d really especially like to know where it’s from if it’s sourced.
FYI this is all based on a neck pour, if I adjust my view I'll be back. But so far...what an over priced bottle and I had to scream it from the roof top.