cascode
Aerstone Land Cask 10 Year
Single Malt — Scotland
Reviewed
March 18, 2021 (edited April 8, 2024)
Nose: Soft autumnal peat smoke with woody and vanilla overtones. There is a maritime quality but it’s certainly not “medicinal” or iodine-tinged. Maybe it’s actually more of a farmyard quality. Hmm. Ok, it’s a creosote-soaked driftwood barbecue fire on a farm by the sea shore.
Palate: Briny on the arrival, turning surprisingly sweet as it develops with vanilla and honey clearly noticeable. Light, smoky, but like the nose it’s not at all medicinal and totally unlike an Islay peat flavour. Fruit, barley-sugar, butterscotch and that same autumn-dusk tinged woody character. The texture is agreeably soft with just a touch of brine.
Finish: Short. Soft, sweet fruity smoke that drifts off and quickly dissipates.
I have to confess I was not expecting much from this whisky but it was surprisingly satisfying and enjoyable. It’s not a coastal smoky whisky at all – banish any thoughts of Islay, Mull or Skye from your mind. The most similar whisky I can think of would be Ardmore however this is from a lowland distillery (the official Distiller scope notes do not mention it, but this is from Ailsa Bay distillery, located at the Girvan plant in Ayrshire).
This is a pleasant dram, but the official Distiller rating is far too high and the official tasting notes are absurd. It’s nothing earth-shattering - just an agreeably mild (in fact very mild) lower-shelf peated whisky. It good for the inexpensive price point and a good introduction to the style for novices. More experienced whisky enthusiasts should try a pour before buying as it may seem a little tame or even watery to them.
Tasted from a 30ml sample (thank you @KT66)
“Average” : 75/100 (2.5 stars)
61.0
AUD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@JVin HI! Sorry I missed your comment back in March - just seen it now. I can see how a spike of more smoky whisky would up the ante here without losing the mild presentation. It's amazing how much just a few drops of highly peated whisky can affect even a whole bottle of unpeated whisky.
I always love your comments. with this one, I agree. Ive mixed a 60ml dram of this with about 7-8ml of smokehead and let them marry for 10 min, and the result is OMG, please try it if you can.
@Soba45 My only taste of Ailsa Bay was of expression 1.2 at a pop-up stand in a local liquor shop. I didn't think it was bad as such, but I only rated it 2.75 here and I noted obvious youth and lack of length - it was more like a pedestrian peated blend than a single malt and at $99 a bottle I thought it was very overpriced. This Aerstone is in many ways a mature and more balanced Ailsa Bay at a way better price. @1901 My friend @KT66 has had the "Sea Cask" version as well but he was not impressed by it and did not pass on a sample. He thought this "Land Cask" to be significantly superior.
Ah I was wondering what the distillery was. i thought it was a new one. I had a couple of the distillery's official offerings and they were baaad...both 2.5 which for me is low.
I picked up this and the Aerstone Sea Cask in a UK supermarket a year or two back (for £20 on sale i think) but have yet to open either. Thanks for the review to let me know what’s in store. Sound like a pretty reasonable dram all told.
Had not heard of this before. Distiller’s notes are rather misleading. Good detail.