Skymecca
Pikesville Straight Rye
Rye — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
March 22, 2021 (edited September 13, 2021)
A "barely legal" rye and the higher proof older brother of Rittenhouse Rye, a favorite mixer. I've heard a ton of positive things about this. My favorite ryes so far have been the Russell's Reserve single barrel rye (excellent, heavy spearmint and white sugar profile) and Willett Rye (even better, what I'd describe as honey soaked flowers with a spectacular finish). Where does this place?
This one has a bourbon-style caramel nose with the slightest hint of spice. The first several times I've tried this, it's actually been pretty muted but nice. It certainly doesn't scream rye, merely a nice bourbon. No burn or ethanol, the proof is super friendly.
On the palate and finish, it delivers what I was hoping for - a Willett style honeyed floral taste! It has almost the exact same characteristics as that wonderful Willett Rye, just a little less complicated and intense.
The Willett is about $56 an is unmistakeably superior. However, this is only $42. So basically, this is 75% as good as Willett Rye, but also only 75% of the price. It's a winner in my book and I'll look to stock this, particularly if I can't land a Willett or if my wallet is hurting a bit. Good stuff.
42.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@ghill40509 Absolutely. I should make clear that the 4 Year Willett is one of my favorite whiskies ever, and saying this is 75% as good is intended as high praise.
I like your 75% evaluation. Pikesville is first rate and the 110 proof adds a lot of flavor