skillerified
Eagle Rare 10 Year Bourbon
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
April 18, 2021 (edited July 19, 2022)
N: Ripe berries, caramel, brown sugar, spearmint. Leather with citrus oil. Raw tobacco leaf, or at least what I imagine that smells like. Herby with a lean toward basil, but that's cut through and balanced by the sweeter caramel and brown sugar from before. Oak and cinnamon. More leather and unlit cigar tobacco. More berries and red fruit.
P: The berries hit first, like the nose. Caramel and vanilla follow. Both are well developed, but the vanilla is particularly nice with a palate filling creaminess. Oak and cinnamon next. Good deal of baking spices. Finish is medium long, spicy and tannic. Spice is cinnamon first, but quickly builds and turns to a chili pepper heat - noticeably hot, never overwhelming, really nice. Lots of oak tannin in the finish, but, again, the bitterness eases in and eases out - there are no sharp edges in this bourbon.
I'm not saying anything new here, but this may be the best VFM bourbon on the market. It has the traditional caramel and vanilla notes that you expect (at a minimum) in a value bourbon. But neither of those flavors are presented at minimum here - both are developed and robust with complication, interplay with other flavors, and nuance. Very well done. More interesting, however, is the fruity, berry flavor that leads the way. That is way above the bar for a ~$30 bourbon. This easily drinks like a $60 or maybe even $80 bourbon. This is one to put on repeat.
36.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Nice review...many places put this on the shelf for near $100. The MSRP of $40 for a 10 year old Single Barrel (still emptied one barrel at a time with no batching) is maybe the best VFM in all of Bourbonland. All that being said...sometimes it hits me just right and others I'm just "meh". I do grab a bottle whenever I see it.
@Ctrexman Hmm, I tried Buffalo Trace early in my whiskey journey. Maybe I should return to it. You're definitely deeper into it than I am. I remember it as good, but forgettable. I think I'm generally down on the wheaters, up on rye. Beyond that, I don't know enough about the mash bills.
I honestly like this but do think its a bit overrated. I find Buffalo Trace very close in all aspects . I think Im just getting tired of Bt mashbill#1. #2 on the other hand Im still very interested in