kilchoman machir pear fruity light delicated light color mid pep fruity no smoke 2.25 smoke medicinal peaty light thin and bitter after taste, oaky, but a very strong prominent smoke feature 2.5 oaky and low sustain 2 2.25 2019 / 9th editions creamy herbs, sweet, smoke peatty, smokey, meaty, ash, dryness, drought, peach, peppery 3,25 dense oily, thick, creamy malty, barley, smooth smoke, fruitiness, slight slight bitterness but generally a nice smooth smoky 2.75 mid sustain to low sustian, oaky 2.5 2.75