cascode
Tobermory 23 year old
Single Malt — Isle of Mull, Scotland
Reviewed
June 7, 2021 (edited June 22, 2021)
Nose: Very oloroso driven with nuts, dates, chocolate and orange preserve. Some malt extract notes and raisin/grape aromas. There is a strong sense of very old cask but it is not what I’d call oak-dominated. Maturity shines through but although it is a rich nose it is a little shy.
Palate: The arrival impresses immediately with old, mature dark fruit flavours and a dense, full mouthfeel. The development sees spiced orange notes, black coffee, and buttery caramel coming forwards together with rum and raisin chocolate and walnut brittle. Towards the finish a slight salty tang is noticeable. It responds very well to dilution, gaining in every dimension.
Finish: Medium/long. Very soft milk chocolate and vanilla. Well balanced. There is just a hint of salty orange peel in the aftertaste. A dash of water does not change the profile but adds a creamy quality to the texture and lengthens the finish.
A delicious single malt that was distilled in 1996 and matured in refill hogsheads until 2009, when part of the batch was released as a 15 year old expression. The remainder was further matured in the same hogsheads before being transferred to Gonzales Byass sherry butts in 2014.
Initially I thought this was good but a little too laid-back (even “tired” as if it had been over-matured) but the addition of a little water completely transformed it. A teaspoon of water, a light swirl, and immediately it sprang to life retaining its 23 years of maturity but seeming to gain the sprightliness and spicy verve of a much younger whisky. I cannot recommend a dash of water too highly with this – it is a sleeping giant.
This is not currently available in Australia but it is selling in the UK for £290. I've been quoted AUD$400-600 for when (and if) it makes it out here, which sounds about right, but as nice as it is I’m not sure it quite deserves that price tag. If you have deep pockets it’s a recommended buy, but otherwise I’d make do with a taste, if you can find it. Still, based entirely on quality and ignoring the price I have to rate this highly.
Tasted at the Sydney Whisky Show, May 15 2021, my tasting #9
“Very Good” : 87/100 (4.25 stars)
PS - I made an error for this entry - it should be 46.3% abv, not 46%
500.0
AUD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@Ctrexman It's a distillery that has been plagued by bad luck and the whisky had a poor reputation for a long time. The distillate used to have an overly wide cut and was very feinty but something must have changed around the turn of the millennium because from 2010 the 10 year old suddenly became much better. Sadly, they ceased production (for no good reason) and in 2017 switched to a core-range 12 year old. The 10 had a brisk, citric, vegetal and flinty character that was maritime without being smoky, but the 12 is more fruity and lost the maritime quality. Interestingly, the whisky is matured at Deanston distillery and the modern profile is not unlike Deanston.
Ive wanted to try Tobermory as I am a big fan of Ledaig
That’s a steep asking price for a relatively not well known distillery. One can get a 25yr old Caol Ila for much less