cascode
Woodford Reserve Master's Collection Select American Oak Bourbon
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
June 17, 2021 (edited July 19, 2022)
Nose: Peach flan, dusted with brown and cinnamon sugar, warm from the oven, slightly caramelised and topped with fresh vanilla cream. A cup of strong black coffee spiked with hazelnut syrup on the side. An apple pie with almonds and cloves is still baking. The farmhouse kitchen is full of old but recently waxed oak furniture.
Palate: Nutty and buttery on the arrival – pecans, fresh walnuts and popcorn. The spiced stone-fruits from the nose appear again as it develops, together with caramel, vanilla and lightly astringent oak tannin that veers towards dark bitter chocolate in the finish. The texture is good – mouth coating and silky but with a mild tannic grip.
Finish: Medium/long. Nutty, spicy and oaky.
I’ve not tried many Woodford Reserve whiskies as we don’t get the full range of expressions over here, so my past experience has been limited to the standard release, the Double Oaked, and the truly excellent 125.8 proof Masters Collection bottling. I enjoyed all of those so when I saw the Woodford Reserve stand at the Whisky Show, and particularly several of the tall round Masters Collection bottles, I made sure to include it in my itinerary for the afternoon.
WR were presenting a small range of expressions I’d not encountered before, including this one. I had thought that all the Masters Collection were at high proof, which it turns out is not the case, but the whiskies did not disappoint. This one was particularly enjoyable with an approachable character that was only slightly let down by being a touch unbalanced. When a whiskey is specifically crafted to showcase oak casks it may seem a little harsh to criticize it for being too oaky, but … well, it is. Just a bit.
The price is also highly variable over here. I’ve seen it for as much as $250, as low as $160, and it generally hovers around $200. Even at the lowest price it’s still almost three times as much as the WR core-range straight bourbon. I don’t subtract from a score just because of price, but given that the core-range bottling is almost the same strength and very good in its own right it becomes difficult to recommend this.
Tasted at the Sydney Whisky Show, 15 May 2021, my tasting #13
“Good” : 84/100 (3.75 stars)
200.0
AUD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Thanks for this review! Was about to get an American oak. I’ll stick with the double oak!
Woodford Masters releases are HIGHLY allocated around here(south east USA), if you find one you are guranteed to pay thru the nose for it. If you get one close to 150, you are likely getting a "deal", though I doubt the actual bottle cost is much over 100 if at all. I've collected a couple of them just because I'm a Woodford fan, but these releases generally don't seem to add up to the price point.
@dubz480 Hah! It was also at the Whisky Show and will be my next review! 😀
Great reviews on both of these! As you point out, the Batch Proof WR release is the best of the "Masters Collection" consistently! They did a "Double Double Oaked" as a distillery exclusive that was also excellent. If that ever makes it into wide distribution definitely look out for it!