The Beverage Tasting Institute astutely gave this an "87" noting: "Amber color. Aromas of spiced apple relish, roasted corn, and sultanas with a satiny, crisp, dry medium body and a smooth, delightful, medium-length toasted rye with apple butter, candied ginger, and caramel finish. A solid cocktailing bourbon that hits all the marks." Even though it's only clocking in at 40% ABV, this bourbon DOES have flavor, most likely due to it being sourced from Heaven Hill and "Aged for a minimum of 3 Years." The palate betrays a flavor-profile of a proofed-down Fighting Cock or Evan Williams 1783 with very little finish to savor. Of note, this bourbon is also certified Kosher. A sub-$20 bottle that would surely benefit from more proof, Old Williamsburg is nonetheless perfectly drinkable neat or in a cocktail.