ctbeck11
El Dorado 21 Year Old Special Reserve
Aged Rum — Guyana
Reviewed
September 8, 2021 (edited September 17, 2021)
Nose - rich molasses, butterscotch, allspice, grape, raisin toast, clove, cherry, plum, fig, earthy mint, vanilla, chocolate, coffee, orange, overripe banana, leather, strong oak, moderate ethanol burn.
Taste - butterscotch, molasses, sweet floral notes, vanilla, raisin, dark chocolate, grape, burnt brown sugar, cherry, allspice, toast, leather, tobacco, plum, orange, demerara syrup, mild to moderate alcohol bite, finishing medium long with rich molasses, butterscotch, grape, and baking spice flavors.
I liked the 8 Year. Will I love the 21? The nose is rather surprising. It’s deep and complex, but not as dark as the 8 Year’s. Actually, it’s very reminiscent of a Cognac. Along with the molasses and butterscotch, there are pronounced grape, baking spice, and boozy chocolate orange aromas. The palate has more of that boozy chocolate, some burnt brown sugar, and a hearty dose of dark dried fruits.
Well I definitely like this better than the 8 Year. It’s obviously older, although I wouldn’t say it strikes me as a particularly mature 21 year old rum. There’s a nice buttery oiliness to the mouthfeel that lingers into a rather pleasant Armagnac-like finish. Similar to some brandies though, there’s also a slight, unwelcome sourness to the palate that I wish weren’t as prominent. Nonetheless, this is great rum and one I’d happily sip any day. A big thank you to @ContemplativeFox for providing the generous sample!
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@ContemplativeFox Certainly the first rum I’ve tried where I picked up those notes. Didn’t mention the price in the review. But at $100 a bottle for 21 year old rum, I think this is a pretty decent value as well. I’m surprised it’s not closer to Appleton prices at around $150.
You got it with the Brandy comparison. That really took me by surprise.