PBMichiganWolverine
Foursquare Shibboleth
Aged Rum — Barbados
Reviewed
September 18, 2021 (edited October 30, 2021)
I feel as if I’ve been prejudiced against rum for a long time now. I always associated it with the sweet saccharine drinks that are more suited for lounging on the beach somewhere. That impression really didn’t change when I had my first Caroni ( the now ghosted Trinidad distillery). I assumed the Caroni was a one-off. With its funky earthy diesel fuel induced flavors, it was more Springbank than Captain Morgan. i just thought Caronis were the one-hit wonder of the rum world, and it’s defunct ghosted status was mere proof of its inability to survive in a world where everything else is Captain Morgan or Bacardi.
Foursquare changed that prejudice. These series from their Excellence Mark are amazing. This one is probably one of the oldest that’s aged in the tropics. Aside from Caroni. You would expect 16 years in Barbados would mean you’re about to drink liquified wood, but instead this is dark fruits, earthy, and a tad bit smoky. Hence the name “shibboleth “…which means you would assume one thing, but it’s actually something else.
These are now hard to come by…but lesson learned: Caroni are probably the best, and now almost unattainable, but these Foursquare Excellence series are an annual release and a worthy replacement to the Caroni. Buy it…will be worth the price.
Thanks to @ctbeck11 for sending over this pour !
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Interesting! I just had my mind blown by a rum lately and too thought rum was for those beach drinks only or spiced rum and coke stuff. Nice to see someone else discovering the wonders of great rum! My experience was with Diplomatico Reserva.
@PBMichiganWolverine Hmm, is it possible to have too much whisky? Is there such a thing?
@cascode god no…I have 750 bottles of whiskey sitting in a storage house…any more exploration into other spirits won’t end well for me ;-)
Back in the day there were only two rums we ever saw in Australia - Bundaberg and Beenleigh. Both are terrible - sweet and poor quality. When I was finally introduced to high-ester Caribbean rums I couldn't believe they were all from the same family of drinks. Sad that Caroni is now as rare as hen's teeth, but wonderful that there are so many good contemporary distilleries to take up the mantle. Check out Hampden and Long Pond as well 👍
Glad you like it. My favorite so far has been Nobiliary. I wasn’t the biggest fan of this one when I first opened the bottle, but it’s improved with some oxidation.