pkingmartin
Dunedin Double Cask 18 Year
Single Grain — South Island, New Zealand
Reviewed
November 28, 2021 (edited October 7, 2022)
Many years ago, I had ordered a sample of a New Zealand whiskey that was aged for 25 years from a ghosted distillery that would have cost several hundred for a bottle, but thankfully the sample was available for a reasonable rate. My main memory from that experience was tutti-frutti bubble gum flavored rubber mulch, but thankfully @PBMichiganWolverine was kind enough to send me over a sample of an 18 year old to review. Let’s see if that memory is close or if that was just a bad bottle.
The nose starts with a floral rubbery note almost as if someone decided to put perfume on their Jeep’s tires followed by tutti-frutti bubble gum, sour cherries, and sautéed apples that transitions to ginger, chestnuts and moderate oak spice with low ethanol burn.
The taste is a thin mouthfeel that starts with that floral rubbery note but more like bitter rubber mulch with perfume that you’re chewing on followed by you spitting that perfume mulch out to replace it with chewing a tutti-frutti bubble gum with the wrapper still on, sour cherries, and grapefruit that transitions to ginger, chestnuts, acetone and moderate oak spice with low ethanol burn.
The finish is medium length with rubber mulch, slight red berry flavor and burnt leaf ash.
Well, this one was rough and my memory was very close to what this one tasted like. The nose was a warning of what was to come with sour fruit, rubber and light spices, but the taste is bitter with rubber, perfume, tutti-frutti gum and acetone notes that finishes medium length with light fruit in the background of rubber and ash.
I’m very grateful that @PBMichiganWolverine shared with me a pour from this ghosted distillery and can see why they shuttered their doors after all.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Yes, I wasn't very impressed with this when I tried it earlier this year - definitely below average stuff. The iconic distilleries that were closed or went silent in the 80s and 90s were shut down for purely economic reasons - the owners at the time didn't give a hoot about public tastes or single malts in general. The distilleries either needed major renovations after poor health and safety reports or they were not needed for making blending stock. Willowbank in NZ (where this stuff came from) was a successful distillery that was taken over by Fosters in Australia in 1997, who immediately shut it down and sent the stills to Fiji for rum production, which was seen as a more lucrative enterprise at the time.
I totally agree—-I can see why this one had to close down. I think the likes of Port Ellen, Brora , Rosebank and Karuizawa shut down because their profile wasn’t aligned with the tastes back then, but this….this clearly was subpar. Was good to try a ghosted , and to know not all ghosted were good