ctbeck11
Auchroisk "This is Like Spectacular" Apollo 9, The Whisky Barrel Exclusive
Single Malt — Speyside, Scotland
Reviewed
December 10, 2021 (edited December 12, 2021)
Nose - raisin, chocolate malt, vanilla, nutmeg, vanilla, apple, apricot, orange, light sulphur, moderate ethanol burn.
Taste - raisin, lemon pith, orange zest, dark chocolate, ginger, apple, allspice, nutmeg, vanilla, coffee, cola, black cherry, moderate alcohol bite, finishing medium length with raisin, citrus, and baking spice flavors.
Since this one has been a recent topic of conversation here, I figured I needed to thrown in my two cents from way back here in the peanut gallery. Wow, one whiff of this let’s you know there’s PX involved. There might be more PX than whiskey in this dram.
This is like filling a bathtub with Sunmaid raisins, leaving it to fester for a month, and then diving in and rolling around. There’s also chocolate, baking spices, and something meaty which I’m interpreting as sulphur. Although it might just be a dried apricot note; I confuse the two sometimes. The palate is punchy and bright. The preponderance of PX downplays the youthfulness a bit, but it’s still there. More raisins, bitter citrus, chocolate, and coffee are in the mix as well. The finish is middling with those dark flavors lingering reasonably nicely.
So I don’t hate this, but I don’t love it either. I like a good PX bomb as much as the next guy, but the balance is off here. I have an Edradour 11 Year that’s a total PX bomb as well, but the base distillate seems to stand up better to the dominant sherry influence than this one does. The bigger issue here is the youth and citrusy bitterness that pervades the palate. Still, it’s better than average for me and a really cool one to have the opportunity to try. A big thank you to @PBMichiganWolverine for providing the sample!
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@ctbeck11 agree. My favorite Scotches tend to be sherry-casked, but the scatter is all over the place and I think it’s largely due to the craftsmanship, elegance, and quality of the sherry influence and how well suited it is for the distillate.
@ctbeck11 It's a great way to get rid of stuff that would otherwise be drain pours. Worst case, they're just still drain pours :)
@ContemplativeFox That’s really interesting. Wonder what the explanation is. I might give blending a try a some point. I certainly have enough variety to play around with.
@bigwhitemike I can dig it in certain cases, but it takes a stronger spirit to stand up to it. PX aging specifically seems to be overpowering if not managed correctly.
@ctbeck11 Great point about the casks being wet. I haven't heard it mentioned before, but several months ago I had an epiphany when home blending and tried letting my chips completely dry before using them and the flavor they produced was so much better! I don't think it was just that the volume being blended in was reduced - there had to be some other affect in play, but I'm just not quite sure what it was.
@PBMichiganWolverine @ctbeck11 after hearing good things from many in this group I came across an edradour 10 and that is my same impression.. wouldn’t shock me at all if they announced that it was 50/50 and had “dumped” the sherry with the bunghole midway up the side instead of at the bottom. Tastes good enough, but it hardly qualifies as barreling IMO - more like blending.
@PBMichiganWolverine Wouldn’t be surprised if they were very wet casks. You can smell the PX from across the room.
@ctbeck11 i have a feeling that cask was still half full with PX sherry went the distillate went in