I had this side-by-side in Glen Cairn glasses with Elijah Craig Barrel Proof (Batch A121, 124 proof), and I did my best to dilute both to the same ABV (albeit subjectively by mouth feel and sensation of heat on my palate) to standardize the comparison. Much to my surprise, they were absolutely identical in terms of their aromatics, flavors (spice profile), and mouth-feel. The only difference that I could discern between the two was that the Belle Meade was a little sweeter. To sum it up, since they are both the same price in my area ($69.99, in SE Michigan), the winner of the matchup could go either way: On one hand the the higher proof of the ECBP makes it a better value, but only if you plan to add water. On the other hand, the Belle Meade is more available year-round, making it an advantage if you plan to drink a lot of it!