ctbeck11
High West A Midwinter Night's Dram Act 8 (All Scenes)
Rye — (bottled in) Utah, USA
Reviewed
December 24, 2021 (edited July 1, 2022)
Nose - strawberry jam, anise, earthy mint, cocoa, currant, caramel, vanilla, black cherry, plum, clove, allspice, cinnamon bark, dry oak, mild to moderate ethanol burn.
Taste - strawberry jam, spearmint, clove, anise, cranberry, butterscotch, vanilla, cherry, plum, cinnamon, sour oak, orange zest, moderate alcohol bite, finishing medium length with jammy red fruit, mint, spearmint, anise, and baking spice flavors.
It’s Christmas Eve, and this whiskey has visions of sugar plums dancing through my head. I bought the bottle last year and haven’t had more than a few pours of it since. Let’s hope it keeps the Christmas spirits high. The nose is minty and jammy. Dark red fruits abound with a heavy dose of anise and other baking and rye spices. The palate keeps the mint train rolling, offset with those same dark red, jammy fruits, bark spices, and sour, almost tannic oak.
Well this is good, but I really wanted to like it more. The aromas and flavors are nice, but something’s off. It’s slightly sour and generally feels like it’s lacking some necessary depth. The finish also misses the mark and is borderline thin. Overall, this profile had a lot of potential, but the execution just doesn’t deliver. It seems I’ve missed the glory days of MWND releases. I spent $110 on this bottle last year, and it’s not worth it. I can’t speak for the newest act, but it probably doesn’t deserve a pickup at anymore than retail.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@Scott_E Merry Christmas! I guess people will pay it. One of the reasons I like Distiller is that it helps me to not be one of those people, except in cases where paying extra might be warranted.
@PBMichiganWolverine @ctbeck11 Merry Christmas. I can’t wrap my head around the recent prices. I purchased Act 9 or $125 a few weeks ago. Went to the same shop yesterday for some rye for Old Fashioneds and saw he upped the price to $199. $70 more than 3 weeks prior. Agree with Pranay, Act 2 & 3 were the best. Now it’s like chasing the dragon in hopes of catching the newer ones like days of yore.
@PBMichiganWolverine Good suggestion. Doesn’t look like any of the local shops have it in stock, but I’ll keep it on my radar.
@ctbeck11 try Whipsaw rye——it’’s a red wine finished rye. At $35, not bad VFM
@PBMichiganWolverine Yep. I won’t be buying another anytime soon. Wonder if there are any better options with a similar profile. I do really enjoy that rye and jammy fruit flavor combo.
@ctbeck11 last year’s was okay…nothing like the early glory days of Act 2 & 3. Way overpriced now—-retailers are asking for silly prices on this based on previous glory days