Definitely the younger version of it's other offerings but that creates a lighter and softer version of the standard Lagavulin taste, not a hot or one note dud. Although all tastes are lesser than the 16 or the distiller's (the Guinness 11 is it's own taste) this has it's place in the lineup as a great introductory for those not ready to jump into the depths of Lagavulin 16. It's thinner and sweeter, with slight vanilla and baking spices. It's dry and smokey, but more vegetable smoke than meaty BBQ. It's definitely Lagavulin though. The age is mostly noticable in the lack of Sherry influence compared to the 16. This one is sweeter, but in a candy way, not a berry way. Overall, I wouldn't buy a bottle (this was a gift) since the 16 is my favorite go to sipper and superior in every way for another$20-30 but I would happily sip this when offered. At $50-60 a bottle this is a great way to introduce someone to Lagavulin who is only beginning to dabble in the Islay profiles.