Having tried and been a fan of 12 year Aberfeldy for some time as one of the best bargain single malts on the market, I got a gift pack for a friend for Christmas of 12, 16 and 21. We only recently got into the 16 year and its just fine. Tastes are subjective but I thought this was a little too fruit heavy for my taste. Credit where its due, it is smooth through and through and goes down with no burn. Toward the end of the taste do I detect some dark chocolate sweetness? It's almost chalky. No.. for me, I would save the green and get 12 year or go a little fancier with the 21. But really this whole lineup tastes much pricier than the price point suggests and are actually readily available anywhere. A plus in these crazy times.