Bourbon_Obsessed_Lexington
Elijah Craig Kentucky Straight Rye
Rye — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
June 19, 2022 (edited September 9, 2022)
I have to give it to the EC line - despite being a fanboy of the profile, most of their offerings are still a bargain. That said, I’ve seen prices on this fall from $35 to $25 as it has become more widely distributed.
Nose is a mixture of vanilla, maple syrup, rye bread and spearmint. Palate follows and isn’t anything fancy, but the rye component is evident and balanced with a bit of herbal mint.
Compared to an $18 bottle of Rittenhouse this has less bite and no cinnamon. Compared to a $20-25 bottle of WT 101 rye I would say it has richer sweetness (as compared to the dusty bubble gum sweetness of WT). From what I remember of Sazerac rye the two are close in sweetness and rye character but Sazerac lacked the herbal mint component. But here’s the kicker, against a $65 bottle of Willett 4y rye… it lacks a few things. No black tea or eucalyptus. But as less than half the price, do I care?
This is good enough to sip on its own but would likely make a good Manhattan or Sazerac. That said, I would probably pick RR single barrel rye or Willett 4y if I’m feeling fancy and stick with this for all other occasions, substituting in Rittenhouse and WT 101 rye periodically.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@DjangoJohnson I’m gonna have to give their rye a try - seems like the traditional BF banana notes could make for an interesting, big rye at a great price
This is finally on the coming soon section of FW&GS and I’m excited. I love a bargain rye. Though my preference right now in the price range is Old Forester 100 proof rye.