Davie-Warner
Maker's Mark Bourbon
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
November 25, 2015 (edited December 31, 2020)
Tasted at the Bluebird Inn, Cornwall, PA. I will readily admit, Scotch runs through my veins, I'm not a Bourbon man. But I've kept an open mind for more than a generous amount of time. So after dinner I decided to humor my palate and buy a pour of the ever-popular standard Maker's Mark... and like my father always said, "You'll always pay for an education." Nose? Hot & spicy paint, harsh molasses, floral plantain, mown grass and acetone. touch of sickly-sweet vanilla, almost marshmallow? Once in my mouth it became raw, green wood, freshly varnished oak with a smidgeon of clove. Sweeter and more beer-ish with ice (I never normally add ice to my whisky, this was desperate measures). Drying, Hot cinnamon fireball finish that overstays it's welcome. I honestly can't figure out why anyone would drink this... Maybe because it's cheap? I'm allowing this to become the last nail in the coffin: "I am no longer a WHISK(e)Y drinker, I am a SCOTCH drinker." Dry glass: who knows? I left it half-full on the table.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Brenne is interesting..:wasn't sure what to make of it. Smelled like a really good perfume, and tasted like cognac. Admittedly, I had never heard of Brenne, but met Alison Patel (owner of Brenne) once...and her back story convinced me to buy it.
Amrut and Brenne are on my list... I'm not afraid of World Whisky, just corn-sap moonshine.
Can't disagree ... Maker's is horrible... But popular because it's cheap I guess and better than others that are cheaper or the same price. If you want to try beyond Scotch, give Amrut a chance---really well made whiskey. Especially the Intermediate Sherry