Cornmuse
George Dickel 8 Year Bourbon
Bourbon — Tennessee, USA
Reviewed
July 3, 2022 (edited September 11, 2022)
I'm not a Dickel fanboy, but I could be at this rate. I really loved the Bottled In Bond series, and I've enjoyed the 15 year. I like the Single Barrel Select for a sweeter take on life. This release has been in my sights since it hit the market. It took way too long for me to grab a bottle.
Tasted neat from a NEAT tasting glass from a bottle that's half full and a little more than a week open. A swirl of this coppery liquid shows ample, slow-running legs. I expect a rich mouthfeel and that's exactly what's delivered.
On the nose this is caramel and vanilla, oak and leather, baking spices and fermenting sweet grain. It's not a terribly complex nose, but it's got a number of distinct notes and none of them are bad. This is quite lovely.
On the palate this drinks a little spicier than I expected. There's a really nice sweet introduction that reminds me of the new Jack Daniel's Bottled in Bond. There is some spice here - cayenne pepper and ginger, white pepper and drying oak tannins that makes this a punchy bourbon.
The sweet elements of this are beautifully balanced by the dry, spicy wood. It's rich with heavy cream, a bit of funk, and very light on any minerality. I'd have a very hard time pegging this as a Dickel line extension.
For the going price, this is better than Old Tub or Buffalo Trace (I rated both as a 2.75). Its competitive with Wild Turkey 101, & Elijah Craig and more. This is absolutely a solid bourbon punching above its proof and price class and living in a sub $25 neighborhood. I can't ask for more than that.
23.99
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@BRBNlibrarian I'm looking forward to your feedback. This is a really solid value, maybe even a better value than the JDbib, if not a better whiskey in absolute terms. Worth having on the bar for certain.
I want you to know this is the review that put me over the edge to buy a bottle of this. I’m a huge fan of the new JD Bonded and your notes sound like this will be up my alley. Thanks!
@Ctrexman I just got in a bottle of 12. I need to give it a serious taste, but first impression is that the 8 year bourbon is a better expression. Look for a review (and a comparo of a few options at this price in Discord) later this weekend. i
@Ctrexman I'll have to sbs. I haven't had the 12 in a few years. Bottle incoming for the weekend and I'll let you know.
How does this compare to the 12
I'm a Fanboy, and I say "Come on over, there's room for everyone"!