DrRHCMadden
Dunedin Double Cask 18 Year
Single Grain — South Island, New Zealand
Reviewed
October 7, 2022 (edited November 5, 2022)
“I fear I must blame the french for this. Not because I’m English…”
N: Oak tannins are immediate and slightly mask a stewed fruit compote with lightest vanilla. This nose is delicate, light and softly warming.
P: Drying, astringent wood leads with some light citrus and the beginnings of a dark figgy and jammy body that almost hits a lovely cherry flavour. But then tannic wood cuts back in and stops further development. A syrupy texture is enjoyable.
F: Short. Peppery and oaky and then gone.
I have wanted to try this last frontier of geographical whisky for some time now. The price has come down and the opportunity presented, so I was glad to get in on this. I had really high hopes and wanted this to be excellent. It sadly wasn’t. It was just ok to good. There are two oaks going on here and unfortunately the tannic wood flavours are too powerful. I fear I must blame the French for this. Not because I’m English, but I’m starting to find that European oaks are, if not tempered carefully, aggressive beasts. Six years in American oak and then 12 in French Oak, ooooph. What is here though is light, delicate, and very interesting. It’s a clean spirit and I think these Kiwis may even know what they’re doing, but they’ve let this oak influence build to be a little out of balance in the end.
Distiller whisky taste #82
86.1
AUD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Agreed also - my instant impression when I tasted this at last year's whisky show was "why did they leave this poor beast confined in the same brutal barrel for SO LONG!". It probably would have been much tastier as a 12, but who knows - maybe it needed the tempering of more years - maybe it was just tied up in excise or bankruptcy red tape for several years before they could bottle it.
@DrRHCMadden totally agree. The wine influence was a bit much. I had another NZ Dunedin one called Omaravian, which I though was the same issue…a bit much in the wine influence
@PBMichiganWolverine I think if they pulled this after 6 years in the French we might have a worthy contender…
I really wanted to like this as well, namely because it’s from a ghosted distillery. But, some things are better left dead.