DrRHCMadden
Johnnie Walker Gold Label Reserve
Blended — Scotland
Reviewed
January 25, 2023 (edited January 28, 2023)
I never get tired of the marketing BS that gets put on whisky. Its the equivalent of selling perfume through adverts on the TV. There is an obvious sensory disconnect. Highland Park are the true masters of marketing BS of late I think. I knew nothing of Johnnie Walker Gold. I’m likely mistaken but I think there used to be a travel retail exclusive gold 18, maybe? This Gold Label Reserve is a replacement of that I think and comes with a fairly sensible spiel from the liberal arts grad in marketing:
“Johnnie Walker Gold Label Reserve is a luxurious and smooth whisky, with notes of vanilla and dark fruit – a wonderful tribute to the harmonious partnership of Speyside and Highland whiskies, with just a hint of smouldering embers from the West Coast. Johnnie Walker Gold Label Reserve is made for those unforgettable nights out with amazing friends”
Jokes on you JW Marketing team, I’m in a high back leather chair in blissful peace and quiet. Unforgettable night out indeed.
N: I’ve let this sit for around 15 minutes and there is still some aggressive spirit lingering. Behind the burn though, sticky caramel texture with honey, wood spice, cinnamon, mushy banana and an ever so delicate floral/perfume note all get brought along by a malt heavy nose. A hint of oily smoke, that sadly stops short of where I’d like it to be. Initial burn aside, this is a lovely rich nose built on simplicity.
P: Light, quite dry and just a touch waxy. Honeyed malt is obvious and the main player, some citrus freshness accompany juicy berries and quite prominent florals. Despite an initially drying open this becomes juicier and a touch sweeter with each sip along with a light vanilla. Whilst very well delivered there is a very obvious lack of depth here I’m largely forgetting what its about in-between sips. The best element is the juiciness, but towards the end of the dram I’m actually starting to think it’s a little plain. I hoped to find the smoke that was but a whisper on the nose, sadly not.
F: Medium-long. Surprisingly long, vanilla, toffee and brown sugar linger in a waxy fight between astringent and juicy. Interesting.
Interesting. The grain component here is obvious as the sweetness that builds throughout the delivery, but it doesn’t seem to detract from the malt forward and curiously juicy profile. Perhaps the grain masks some of the wood profile? I don’t know. What is here in the honey, malt, berry fruitiness, and banana are all just fine. The smoke and florals sadly fail to get going, they would have been wonderful elevators of this liquid, but what can you do? Well, my stock standard suggestion in these situations with these profiles: pay less, drink more Monkey Shoulder.
[Pictured here with a (fools) gold mineral for a gold label. This mineral is a pyrite “sun” from Sparta, Illinois, USA. Growing in the ~300 million year old Herrin Coal Measures 50-75 m underground these discs of iron sulphide are formed by anaerobic bacteria decomposing organic matter in black shale layers. The bacterial processes produce chemical conditions that precipitate pyrite. Restricted by the sediments above and below the progressive growth of the pyrite is forced outwards growing elongate bundles that coalesce into a disc. Anyway, THIS. IS. SPARTA. And in Sparta we apparently drink Gold Label]
Distiller whisky taste #147
Johnnie Walker running scores:
Red: 2.0
Black 12: 2.5
Black Islay Origins: 3.5
Double Black: 3.25
Gold: 3.5
98.99
AUD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@DrRHCMadden I'll be interested to read that review. JW Green is very popular and until recently unique in their range, being a blended malt. It was originally a limited edition (hmm, must have been over a decade ago) and it was amazing but was withdrawn after a short run. It was so popular they brought it back and although very good it was not *quite* as good as the original release. I do feel that over time it has lost a little something, but lat time I tasted it a few years ago it was still graet value. That was when you could easily find it for AUD$65 (sometimes as low as $55) but now it is around $80-85 usually and facing stiff competition.
@PBMichiganWolverine nope, but; am picking up a bottle tonight.
@angstrom Agreed about the marketing blurb.
The best of the upper-middle band JW range was the old Platinum 18 year old, which was withdrawn a few years ago. None of the Gold or age statement expressions has come close to it.
@DrRHCMadden Hey, watch it with the liberal arts jibes, dirt monkey 😉
@DrRHCMadden I have a feeling I asked you this before…but I forget…have you tried the JW Green? Amazing VFM.
@PBMichiganWolverine yes, definitely a new level of bullshit. But, liberal arts grads need jobs. Support the unfortunate.
@angstrom in the honeyed-malt flavour category I think MS is hard to beat. I never had Good 18, but yes; as I understand it the wood elements were more present. I am hoping to find these in the 18 when I get there over the next week or so.
@pkingmartin @angstrom @DrRHCMadden whiskey and coffee….didn’t the Irish already come up with that? Oh…but Macallan took it to another level (aka bullshit level) by decoupling the whiskey from the coffee, and having a carton made from coffee husk. And the music video. Only if Jameson signed on U2 for an Irish coffee advertisement…
I used to like JW Gold, but that was several iterations ago, I think it had an age statement then. I think what I liked is now more like JW 18, and this has become their fancy highball mixer - thus I love the Monkey Shoulder comment, so true.
Great review! Personally, I think the Marketing speak on this one is good - I can actually translate easily to real concepts that are correctly applied to this whiskey.
@pkingmartin whisky and coffee, oh dear. And music video? What the heck?!
Wonderful review and really love the mini Spartan shield rock! Macallan might be outdoing HP with their Rich Cocoa and Intense Arabica whiskies coming out. I especially like that they recommend the whisky to pair well with coffee. They even have a coffee video for it at https://www.themacallan.com/en/inside-the-macallan/serves/intense-arabica-tasting-ritual. To my knowledge, Macallan is also the only distillery to make a music video.