DrRHCMadden
Smokehead Rum Rebel
Single Malt — Islay, Scotland
Reviewed
March 4, 2023 (edited March 7, 2023)
The last of the three pack and for that matter of the easily accessible Smokeheads. A middling run ending on a revisit to something I last tried on the 26th June 2022 (Original review down below). I remember being perfectly happy sipping on this last year but, let’s revisit…
N: Definitively younger than I remember. Islay smoke is obvious and upfront, but the spirit, slightly burning ethanol presence brings with it bright and zesty pineapple. There is also some toffee here that I don’t recall and some ashy-vegetals. Less rubber than the Smokehead Original and none of the metallic-mineral heavy notes I picked up in the high voltage. A different, and somewhat less characterful nose than the regular cask offerings.
P: Straight in with a fruit juice texture that is a little thin but with some oiliness. Turns quickly to rubbery peat smoke, ashiness akin the original. Definite brininess that trends towards cured meat, but I don’t get quite as clear bacon flavour as I noted before (this is not Talisker). Fruit develops with time, but its not well developed it heads in a bright and fresh direction but stops short at cheap tropical fruit juice and cola bottle sweets. Salt and ash are the take aways here.
F: Long, warming pepper staying away from chilli heat. Feels slightly waxy with a little light vanilla and orange and a pleasant cool smoke.
OK. Smokehead, fair name for this bottling. The smoke, its there. The Rum Rebel part, not so much. It tries to get going, but falls short. I feel like the whisky was told stories about what rum is like and was asked to make a counterfeit copy. It’s lack lustre and detracts from the good elements. I stand by the notion that this is pleasant enough to sip on, but its forgettable and lacks a unifying quality to tie the different threads together.
Smokehead overall is perfectly fine. It has a definite target market, and I’m certain that the appeal is there. But for me, across the board, there are better or cheaper alternatives that easily surpass these. Worth a try, and I might even get one in a bar depending where I am. Would I buy a bottle though? No.
[Pictured here with another skull for a skull branded whisky. Strap in… your’e getting a long story here: meet ‘Peking Man’ a composite representing some forty individuals from a collection of 200 H0mo erectus pekinesis bones dating back 680,000-780,000 years. The bones were excavated from Zhoukoudian cave, China during the 1920’s to 1930’s, and were well studied with many casts being taken. Alongside the H. erectus bones were findings of animal remains and strong evidence for the use of fire and tools. Evidence was also found for the first time of hominids manufacturing their own tools. In 1941 during the Japanese encroachment into China during World War II, a Chinese official, Hu Chengzi packaged the Peking Man collection up to send to the USA for secure housing. The bones were loaded onto a U.S. Marine transport ship but, the bones never arrived. Hu to this date was the last person to see these fossils, which are amongst the most important paleontological finds in history. Their huge importance is not to be understated, Peking Man may be instrumental for developing our understanding of early cannibalism by our ancestors (due to the nature of the fossil find), the origins of speech and language, use of fire and manufacturing of tools. Luckily though the original casts are still yielding some new information. The search for the fossils is currently settling on a Chinese shopping centre parking lot and if recovered would allow modern forensic approaches to look deeper into the origins of humanity from the worlds 'oldest' missing person case.]
Smokehead running scores:
Smokehead Single Malt: 3/5
Smokehead High Voltage: 3.5/5
Smokehead Rum Rebel: 2.75
***
Original review 26th of June 2022
N: Islay peat is undeniable, some iodine and fresh seaweed, chargrilled pineapple.
P: savoury. Bacon and darkness. Thick caramel stickyness. Salty brine.
F: prickly but long. Waxy with light vanilla notes and residual wafts of smoke.
Flavours are perhaps punctuated and not well rounded/balanced but perfectly enjoyable. If on offer/discount would be a pleasant everyday smoky sipper.
3/5
Distiller whisky taste #32
106.99
AUD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@Ctrexman it’s a shame really, a disservice to Islay greatness. Makes Islay seem like a gimmick.
Thanks for the great info. I found this decent but overpriced leading to a no go as well