Robert_McKay
Old Forester 100 Proof Bourbon
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
March 19, 2023 (edited March 6, 2024)
I got a fifth of this whisky for $24.99 at Kelly Liquors in the Mountain Run Shopping Center in Albuquerque. The mash bill is 72% corn, 18% rye, and 10% barley. There's no age statement, and it's 100 proof. In the glass the color is new copper.
NOSE: I came back to the nose several times, and got more notes each time. In the order in which I discerned them, I got corn, grass, honey, cinnamon, a spice which might have been paprika, honey, vanilla icing, milk chocolate, a little bit of smoke (hickory?), a very faint oakiness (I don't believe I've ever gotten oak on the nose before), and buttered roasting ears.
MOUTHFEEL: Initially it was creamy, but on subsequent sips it seemed like the creaminess was slightly watered down.
TASTE: Honey, candy orange slices, red pepper, oak, and lemon. I'm getting used to not getting as much on the tongue as I get on the nose, but this is a big difference.
FINISH: Long, beginning with oak, then black pepper, walnuts, and some jalapeño in the throat.
SUMMARY: I like the metal screw cap on this bottle. A cork doesn't improve the whisky, and a cap is easier to deal with. This is good bourbon. However, it lacks the notes I've come to expect as typical of bourbon - bananas, caramel, and butterscotch. And I'm not sure it's significantly better than the 86 proof expression. The proof is, yes, 14 points higher, but I don't think the taste is correspondingly better.
RATING: Fine (just above good, the third rating down).
24.99
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
I'm on my third glass now, and it's better than I reviewed it. 🥃