Nose: similar nose to #1. I get caramel sweetnest, rye, rye spice and the woodinville nose. Body: medium - full. I like the body of two more than 1, more robust. Palate: caramel, rye breadiness and vanilla sweetness Finish: light to medium and sweet Note: sample #2, i really liked sample one, how will this compare? This is similar but more robust and sweet. At the same time it has fewer rough edges.