I waited until I got a second shot at this to rate it. Both glasses were free, so money wasn't a factor. I don't think this malt differentiates itself enough from the rest of the core range. To me, it only promises a refinement of the flavors in the 12 and the 18 (I like the brashness of the 12, but I will happily drink the 18). It was really good (hence, four stars), but there's no way in hell I'd pay to drink it.