ScotchingHard
Springbank 10 Year Old Palo Cortado Cask Strength
Single Malt — Campbeltown, Scotland
Reviewed
April 2, 2024 (edited June 5, 2024)
Springbank 10 Year Palo Cortado is bottled at 55.0% ABV. It was distilled in July 2013 and bottled in September 2023. It is a limited release of 10,200 bottles. I do not know what the MSRP is, but you will likely not find it at MSRP unless you know people. I bought my bottle for $190, and this is going for $400+ on the secondary market.
This needs to be said: Springbank is becoming Macallan. They may still be “making whisky the right way”, but there has been a drop off in quality, collectors have sucked this well dry, and nonsense whisky Youtubers are jerking off nonstop to these releases, asking questions like, is this best Springbank ever? No. This Palo Cortado, or any Springbank recently released, is not the best Springbank ever. Not even close. I haven’t had a good Springbank since their Local Barley series were on the shelves in the $100-200 price range.
I may have been more enthusiastic about this Springbank release if I had not tried one other palo cortado matured whisky before: an independent bottling of 15-year-old Bruichladdich released by North Star. This release was limited to 264 bottles, bottled at 57.1%, and retailed at $300. I bought multiple bottles, and this is one of my top 10-20 all-time bottles. This Springbank 10-year palo cartado is simply okay. It makes me miss the Bruichladdich, that’s for sure. It is different, of course, from the standard Springbank 10-year-old, but it’s about the same in overall whisky enjoyment. If you can still find a regular Springbank 10-year-old at $100, it’s a safer bet than paying whatever premium to acquire this bottle.
Younger Springbanks just do not do well with wine finishes. Bruichladdich seems to be the distillate for such casks; and if we’re calling Springbank the new Macallan, then Bruichladdich may as well be the new Springbank. However, I do wonder if this palo cartado finish would have been better suited for Springbank’s more rugged Longrow distillate, as in another addition to the Longrow Red series. As is, this Springbank just feels too young. You get an amplified earthy, briny Springbank 10, which is good; but then you get an awkward red fruit and peanuts; and the moderate peatiness is a third dimension that also feels out-of-place in a frustrating composition that seems as though the sum is less than the parts. It makes you wonder if they would’ve been better off just bottling the regular Springbank 10 at cask strength. Even for their Springbank 12 cask strength releases, I’ve found that I enjoy the releases that are more ex-bourbon more than the releases that are more ex-sherry.
I think, over the next few years, it will be more and more acceptable to put down Springbank in a review. How a whisky is made is only interesting and important if the whisky actually tastes amazing. So, for now, the public service announcement is this: don’t suck someone’s dick for a Springbank. It may not be worth it.
190.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Just to add more, these weren't cheap casks (macallan???). This wasn't proofed down. And springbank isn't doing that anywhere. Their cask quality is actually improving. Their local barley's aren't being produced in larger quanties, and I just paid 190 for one of the 13' years. Don't blame the company for speculators. Nothing wrong with not liking this, but don't review based on price. Springbank doesn' think these are 400 dollar bottles. They want you to pay about 80 pounds with vat (ok not sure if that's with or without vat). But that said the CS aspect is easily worth a 25% premium and the unique and expensive casks are worth another. That's not far off what you paid and frankly...I think we all get upset that a few stores have these bottles sitting so we keep seeing them. Most bottles still sell at MSRP. Maybe not so much in NY and Cali...but the rest of the country...we got that one shop that does it. And the rest of the shops don't.
Man, I have to strongly disagree with at least the path of springbank. They've putting out some of their best 18 year old bottles, the 15 has improved...and yeah, this is a series that's not supposed to be GOOD! It's supposed to be an experiment and sadly in the US, we're getting screwed on the 170-190 MSRP by the importer. And then stores and distributor for some are going further. This should be about 100-150 bucks and with inflation that's a VERY fair price. Is it good? Well no...and as one of those springbank loving whiskytubers...I didn't say it was on the camera either. It's over priced and not my cup of tea. But this is a showcase series of their malt with different casks. That's a cool concept and one I'm ok paying a bit for.
Lol, another classic @ScotchingHard joint! Only you can drop some vivid imagery to paint a picture and bring the point across. I’m here for all that! Unfortunately, I got bamboozled into picking up this bottle (+ the 15Yr & 10Yr) Springbanks last weekend…clearly before I read your review. Good news is I did NOT “suck anyone’s dick” to get them 😂