drlewis
Penelope Architect Build No. 8
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
May 19, 2024 (edited May 20, 2024)
Penelope Architect Series Build #8 [2024?]. MGP-sourced straight four grain bourbon whiskey (Corn, Wheat, Rye, Malted Barley) blended from three bourbon mash bills, aged four years, finished with two different french oak staves, and bottled by Penelope in Bardstown, KY at 104 proof. Tasted neat.
Rose copper in color with strong coating legs in the glass. Nose is prominent and inviting: spicy grass/rye, sweet stone fruit, floral vanilla oak, tannins, and ethanol. Great first impression. Vanilla and tannic oak, brown sugar, and an ethanol burst open in the mouth. Cherry, sweet grain, and leather, followed by a peppery spicy taste that carries through into the finish. Coating mouthfeel that thins in a long lip-tingling finish. No sour or off flavors in this whiskey that drinks like it's higher proof than 104.
So it's MGP Ross and Squibb whiskey from Indiana that the folks at Penelope have been tweeking and blending to good reviews. So good that Penelope is now owned by R and S, and as such that team will have even more access to the full range of quality MGP distillates.
Yeah, quality. Big isn't always bad. MGP is making better whiskey than plenty of small craft distilleries, and doing so at scale for years. So instead of lamenting their "standardized" flavors that show up in so many other sourced whiskies (many that hide their MGP source, which is really the problem), acknowledge that MGP juice is better than what some of these "craft" distillers will ever make. High West in my state is a classic example of a great blender of MGP product that has ruined the brand by mixing in their own inferior distillate at jacked prices (and I'm being kind). Point is, plenty of people have taken MGP juice and tweeked it to good effect--Penelope among them--and others have just made their own poor "craft" whiskey that we regret buying in the end. Don't get me wrong, I love quality liquor however it's produced, and I celebrate small distillers risking it all to make amazing juice, but it all comes down to quality, not scale.
Ok, done ranting. Enjoy whatever you choose to drink.
This bottle will divide people over the French oak finish. I happen to appreciate that different flavor profile, and an ice cube changes it again, taming the tannins and ethanol and letting the oak shine. I'm going to keep enjoying this and see how I feel about it next week.
Just another interesting day to be alive. Cheers.
65.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@PBMichiganWolverine @drlewis totally agree about HW. Their earlier products were pretty darn good. The costs reasonable too. In the end , as you stated, quality is the name of the game (with reasonable pricing)
Yeah, HW were good blenders, but even they couldn't blend in their own whiskey with MGP product to taste as good as the MGP alone. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
@drlewis totally agree on High West. They were one of my favorites, until they got bought out and started making their own. Quality went down and price went up