I'm not sure if it deserved all the hate. Oak charcoal, corn pops cereal, boiled grains, lot of dutch cocoa, tobacco, black pepper, allspice, anise, heather honey, graham crackers, nutty, cream soda, ginger chews, candied pecans, brown butter, lemon peel. More medium than heavy but it does need some oxidation before opening up. Promised and delivered smoke while managing to balance it quite well. Would've liked to see a higher abv and another 1-3yrs.