This was one of the whiskies provides by @Telex for our hotel room tasting session the night before Whiskyfest. Once a year (for a week or two) Caol Ila switches production from their normal peated style to produce a small amount of unpeated whisky. This 17 year old is one of the results of their experimenting. Bottled at cask strength of 55.9% ABV and I’m willing to bet it’s non chill filtered. It’s Diageo so I can’t exactly say if there is colorant or not but the color is a yellow gold. The nose starts with lemons and lemongrass, not unlike the regular Caol Ila minus the peat, plus oak, salt/brine and green olives. Some sweetness comes through with honey, pineapple, grapes, berries, blackberry jam, oranges and apricots. It’s slightly herbal and earthy with a little chalky note. Some brown sugar rounds it out. Water brings out more of the oranges and apricots. Too much water brings more of the olive brine, which for me is a bad thing. A strong and powerful palate. Hot. Heavy on the olives and lemons. Some ginger, oak, apricots and dried pineapple. Water tones down the heat, but doesn’t help the flavor at all, just more of the olives. Medium to full bodied, hot and mouthwatering. The finish is medium long, vegetal, olives and oak. Well, it’s not quite bad but not quite good either. Pretty much a hot mess. Caol Ila should stick to peated, or if they are going to continue with this unpeated style they should change up the cask type and throw some sherry at it. It might add some much needed sweetness and fruitiness. The vegetal/olive notes were the downfall here, otherwise it would have been serviceable. Also, at $145 it’s not a great value for a 17 year old. 3.5 and I think that’s a fair mark. Cheers