Is this a whisky or a rosé? You could be forgiven for asking yourself that when this Madeira cask finish is sitting in the glass, blushing at its audacity. A delicate berry bouquet extends the illusion for a beat, until the classic Laphroaig aromas stamp their presence on the occasion. The fruity notes continue in the mouth, with strawberry and Luxardo maraschino cherries sandwiching the signature smoke. It's a more satisfying blend than the Portwood edition or the PX, if not in the same league as the 2014 Cairdeas.