Some distilleries click with me some don't. Edradour doesn't. It doesn't do terrible stuff it doesn't do great stuff. Balance, body and complexity is how I rate whiskey and Edradour nearly always falls at the first hurdle. This time is no exception. Still a good whiskey with rich wine really shining through but very disjointed flavor profile. Still my 1st or 2nd pick of this distillery. 3.75 - The individual parts carry the day despite the sum of them not adding up.