Hi @zippy, I of course respect your opinion but it was really creepy experience. And funny thing - maybe tho is because of decades spent in the corpo but when someone says "with all due respect" it is very seldom that there will be some respect afterwards. Just because of that (and because we have partial notes now) - an upgrade to you my friend ;)

With all due respect I think your missing the mark. This is not a single malt traditional Islay, its a blend. Certainly worthy of more than 1 star. Peace and cheers