Erogers100
Craigellachie 13 Year
Single Malt — Speyside, Scotland
Reviewed
March 2, 2017 (edited November 21, 2019)
Visual: In the glass it is colored somewhere between a pilsner and a hefeweizen. A few good swirls create a few thin legs.
Nose: If anyone ever questioned that scotch is distilled beer, this dram is proof. It is very malty/yeasty like a good craft ale with the intensity turned up to 11. There is also some spiciness almost like its whiskey counterparts this side of the pond – reminiscent of rye. After some rest, a few vegetal (carrot) and grassy notes waft in, along with caramel and oak notes. I also get the “cobblestones after the rain” quality that @Damon Williams notes.
Palate: Honey sweet, followed by arrival of spicy rye-like notes. Brown sugar mid-palate. This dram has a lot of presence on the palate – it is much less subtle than many of its Speyside cousins. It’s not a bludgeon, but it’s not delicate, either. There’s a bitterness on swallowing that is not unlike the hoppiness of beer, but without the citrusy notes found in a highly-hopped IPA. Sorry for the repeated beer analogies, but for some reason this whisky seems to keep reminding me of it.
Finish: The finish is medium long and warming, with the hoppy bitterness continuing for a while, along with some medium-roast coffee notes and lingering brown sugar. Exhalation through the nose results in some aromas that remind me of Rittenhouse Rye.
All in all, I really like this one, and agree with @Revkev12 that it is a singular dram, although he picked up many notes I did not, and vice versa. I didn’t pick up as many fruity notes as others. However, for a Speyside, I thought it was exceptionally full and rich, with a lot of bourbon/rye qualities – as well as beer-like notes. I’ll certainly revisit this one. This is worth every bit of 85 points for a solid 4 stars. A hearty recommendation for those who want to try a Speyside that’s a little different than some others, or for bourbon/rye fans that are developing an appreciation for single malt scotch.
Postscript: Given that scotch whisky is essentially distilled beer, it is amazing how few scotch reviews reference beer. This label screams “I am beer intensified,” IMHO.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review