And a rather high 4 stars, at that. My favorite bartender at my favorite whiskey bar lists this among her favorites, and she's definitely on to something here. Deceptively smooth for 100 proof, the nose is earthy-sweet and spicy, with an almost funky caramel, black pepper, and hints of peppermint (not candy, but the herb itself). The palate starts off with a little boozy heat, but that gives way to a chewy caramel, almost mushroomy savoriness, pepper, spice, and mint. The finish is medium-long and smooth, with a little bit of charcoal to be found. This is one of the least sweet bourbons I've had, and I love it for that.