This definitely gets a 4 - early 4's I'd say and is now my new favorite Glenfiddich overtaking the red wine one. Its one of the few times a low abv actually works turning this into an almost full bodied dessert whiskey liqueur without excessive sweetness. Now at $120USD a bottle I wouldn't be buying a whole one but if you want a good example of the style or perhaps rather to say an example of a strong Maderia influence this is it. As others have noted not a long complex finish or really even a complex anything but the rest of the experience means that this isn't really a major detraction