Richard-ModernDrinking
Laphroaig Càirdeas 2017 Cask Strength Quarter Cask Edition
Single Malt — Islay, Scotland
Reviewed
June 7, 2017 (edited April 16, 2019)
Whisky festival pro tip: There's often a special bottle or two lurking among the core lineups that the distillery representatives are offering at their tables. Often it's something stashed under the table that can be coaxed out after you've paid lip service to the core range and wondered out loud how it compares to that new limited edition you've read about. Sometimes it can be hiding in plain sight, inside the tube of a regular bottling. But if you're at the Laphroaig table, check the Wellington boots. That's where, amid a peat field diaorama, I recognized the red loop of the 2016 Cairdeas just about visible inside one green wellie. And was that a golden hoop I spied in the second wellie? Could it be the new Cairdeas, I asked the kilted fellow filling glasses at the Astor Center Whisky Spectacular, who turned to be none other than brand ambassador Simon Brooking? Indeed it was, he said, fresh from the Islay festival. And what a lovely treat it turned out to be. I've posted two dismissive notes here about the Quarter Cask in as many days, but this cask strength version is a different beast. It's sweet and oily, and the drying tannins of the core version are mostly obscured by the rich honey flavors that linger. It's hard to make nuanced judgements in such circumstances, but this is unmistakably a good Laphroaig and worth checking out when it hits the stores in August.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@Telex: I think they should have this on the shelves here in the US in a few weeks. I'm a bit hesitant personally, since the QC was the only Laphraoig I didn't like. Will need to taste test it before I put down $80-100
Oh, you had me at Quarter Cask, sir. Who do I need to rough up to get my hands on this? Just kidding. I'll have to find someone to sweet talk somehow.
Great review, Richard. I've got 2 bottles coming my way and can't wait to try this one. I love the QC and the thought of a cask strength version really excites me. I give them a "C" for Feis Ile originality but I hope an "A" for final presentation. Cheers.
Oh never mind---just noticed you already described the comparison above...I wrote before reading
What was your take on the Laphroaig QC? I didn't like it, which makes me think I should avoid this CS version of it. But was curious to get your take between the two
Tried this again as part of a full Feis Ile flight and it was just as yummy. I'd rank it fourth among the eight bottlings I tried.