Generously_Paul
Balvenie Single Barrel 15 Year
Single Malt — Speyside, Scotland
Reviewed
June 22, 2017 (edited March 18, 2018)
Stop number 22 on the SDT is Balvenie. This is my first review of Balvenie, but not the first I've had. This Speyside single malt was matured in a European oak ex Oloroso sherry butt (500L) for 15 long years. Bottled at 47.8% ABV and it appears to be natural color of an amber gold. It is also non chill filtered. This sample was generously provided by Pranay and was poured from bottle number 15, from cask number 2639.
Initially on the nose it is somewhat atypical of a Speyside scotch. A definite spice to it with some darker sherry notes. Raisins, red berries and spiced Christmas fruitcake. Strong European oak with cinnamon and toffee. There is also some light vanilla and honey mingling in with the heavier spices. Some bitter orange peel and cocoa powder in the background. After some time to breathe, the more typical Speyside notes start coming through. Oranges and yellow apples and maybe some apricots. Definitely needs time to get past those pungent oak spices. It's very interesting and intriguing and not at all redundant like the beginning of this sentence.
Quite the spicy arrival on the palate. Heavy oak and wood spices. Much like the nose, there is a sweetness buried under the spice. Sherry notes and orchard fruits like oranges and cinnamon dusted pears. Some dark chocolate bitterness in there as well but it's mild. The palate really had more of the typical Speyside notes than the nose did, but it's all dominated by the spice level.
Medium to full bodied with a nice oiliness to the mouthfeel. It's mouthwatering at first but turns fairly dry. The finish is medium long with apricots and that ever present spice carrying through.
The first Balvenie I had was the 12 year Doublewood and I had it on the very first day of my journey into the world of scotch. Couldn't stand it honestly, but after trying this 15 year old I wouldn't mind revisiting it. I remember there being a lot of spice to it and that's probably why I didn't like it, so that's what I was expecting here. I got all that spice but I can now appreciate it. The European oak really did its job and the sherry influence was just enough to add some depth of character. Not sure if this expression is still available or if they have moved exclusively to a 12 and 25 year single barrel, but according to Pranay this one was around $100. Not really worth it in my opinion (all Balvenies seem to be overpriced), but I wouldn't turn down a dram if offered either. A solid 4 though. Cheers
CORRECTION: I was under the impression that this was the sherry cask matured version and not the older bourbon cask version. I was incorrect. Please take any reference to European oak and replace it with American oak. I'm surprised they got this level of spice out of ex bourbon barrels though!
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
To quote or malt mate Ralfy upon discovering a mistake: 'Ah, what the heck, I am having fun!'
To error in the pursuit of joy, this is not pride, but passion. 😀
Ouch, my pride... In any case, it's a good scotch and I recommend it if you like the spicier ones.
( Oh---for those not in our little SDT tour...I'm the one in this little team that is notorious for lack of descriptions, horrible handwriting on the bottles, poor packaging, bottles oozing out their precious liquid, etc...so, theoretically...probably my doing more so than Paul's. My only redeeming quality...I'm a guru with the excel sheets used for tracking our scores ;- )
The kicker is, now that I read it in full, how descriptive it is with cask numbers and bottle numbers...but, a totally different malt altogether. It's like a surgeon that is describing to the patient the intricacies of the kidney transplant he just did, only for the patient to tell him "wait...I came here for an appendectomy". Paul---you just made my morning. ;-)
Wow, this is one of the biggest mistakes to come out of Detroit since the Chevy Monza. :)
Sounds like more proof that I write too much lol. Perhaps more info about the bottle at trade time would have prevented this mistake... I'm looking at you Pranay!
On a side note---this also shows Slainte read the whole thing while I skimmed the first sentence and last...
Or you can copy and paste to the Sherry cask version, and pretext it " if I were to have this, I think this is what I'd feel" 😊
Dammit! Now I have to rewrite the whole thing and remove all references to European oak
Paul, I sent over the old Boubon cask. Not the new Sherry cask.
I stand corrected, this is the sherry cask version. I didn't even see the difference when searching.
Are you sure you have reviewed the 'old' Balvenie 15 (ex-bourbon cask), or was it the new 15-year-old sherry cask? https://distiller.com/spirits/the-balvenie-single-barrel-sherry-cask-15-year
I've not seen these around anymore, I think they've stopped making it.