I don't think I'm all that great at distinguishing non-peated scotches, particularly compared to the peated scotches that are my true love. Tonight, my wife and I tried the "big three" -- this guy, Glenlivet 12, and Glenmorangie Original. To be honest, I could not really tell Glenfiddich 12 and Glenlivet 12 apart, particularly on the nose. It's full of malt, a bit of young spirit, and a fruity apple or apple skin scent. A hint of muskier oil is the only thing distinguishing this one from Glenlivet 12 to me. The taste has some of that sweet malt and apple, but also a bit of a medicinal, cough syrup dimension. The mouthfeel is quite watery, and that hampers the finish, which is short and a bit too herbal or grassy for my tastes. This was my least favorite of the three, just barely (found I wasn't loving the Glenlivet 12 today either).