Dreaming-of-Islay
Colonel E.H. Taylor, Jr. Four Grain Bourbon
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
September 21, 2017 (edited September 22, 2017)
This bourbon gets its name from its unconventional mash bill, which includes both wheat and rye (almost all bourbons opt for either corn-rye-barley or corn-wheat-barley combinations). Rye tends to produce spicy flavors, and wheat tends to produce lighter, fruitier, sweeter flavors, so it's a wonder that more brands don't try this type of experiment. While I applaud the inventive attitude, however, this drink struck me as a little weak. The nose features some unusual flavors, including hoisin sauce, cereal grains, and musty wet oak and leather. The palate surprisingly hits a strong rye chord, has a bread-like yeast flavor, and is quite tannic, which indicates a decent amount of aging. The combination of tannins and sweeter fruit notes in the midpalate are reminiscent of a Burgundy wine. The tannins somewhat obscure the fact that the mouthfeel is not very oily and may even be watery on some sips. This finishes like a rye-based bourbon, with an herbal and spicy kick. Overall, the wheat did not express itself as strongly as I anticipated. Not what I was expecting, and not (to my tastes) worth the hype.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
I agree completely re different tastes and palates, it's why I enjoy hearing other whiskey lover's thoughts. For what it's worth I had this at a bar in New Orleans (Bourbon House) that charged a reasonable (given its rarity and secondary market prices in the multi-hundreds) price of $10/oz for it (in Miami some places charge that much an ounce for Eagle Rare!).
this is what's so great about individuality of tastes...I loved this, thought it was best bourbon I've had in a while. Expensive as heck, not sure I'd buy a bottle at retail price...but, for less than $100, I'd fill up a cart.