TheNeonDram
Macallan Fine Oak 15 Year
Single Malt — Highlands, Scotland
Reviewed
September 26, 2017 (edited April 5, 2018)
More like The Macallan 15 Just Fine.
This dram reminds me of a Broadway show using the same cast for 15 years. Capable? Absolutely. Talented? No doubt. Provide entertainment? Sure. Passion and soul within that performance? That’s where this one seems to get lost.
It just seems kind of soulless. That’s disappointing from a scotch of this caliber.
The elements are there. On the nose, rich vanilla with subtle citrus, dried fruits and candied notes. It’s smooth on entry with a medium mouth feel. However, that smooth entry morphs into a bolder heat that is simultaneously calming and harsh at times.
This scotch isn’t terrible. In fact, what’s here, makes for some fun discussion. Sadly, it feels like this one is phoning it in or distracted and that keeps it from reaching its full potential. This leaves you feeling short changed for the price of admission.
(OOtB September)
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
I completely agree with you. This was just so neutral and underwhelming. Especially when you consider its cost.
Great review. I felt the same way about the 17 year Fine Oak, so I’d encourage you to avoid it as well. Cheers.